Why Your Painting’s Subject Matter isn’t What’s Important

When you stand in front of a painting at an art museum, it’s natural to lean in and focus on what you’re looking at. Is it a serene landscape, a vivid portrait, or an intricate still life? These “what” elements—the subject matter in art—may seem like the star of the show. But what if I told you that the subject itself is not what truly matters in painting?

At the core of impactful art lies something much deeper. It’s not about what you’re painting, but rather how you paint it. This article will explore why the subject matter in art plays a secondary role to the techniques, elements, and personal vision that bring it to life.

Painting is About More than the Objects it Depicts

When we think about iconic paintings like Vincent van Gogh’s Starry Night, Johannes Vermeer’s Girl with a Pearl Earring, or even a bowl of fruit by Cézanne, what draws us in isn’t just the subject matter. Sure, a star-filled sky or a mysterious figure might initially catch your attention. But the magic lies in how the artist has treated the subject. The subject matter is merely a scaffolding upon which to build the real subject.

Take Shakespeare as an example. Many of his plots were borrowed from older stories. Yet, what made his plays immortal was not the plot but his masterful character development, poetic language, and storytelling craft. The same applies to painting—the raw subject (say, a bowl of oranges) is only a jumping-off point. The true artistry lies in how the subject is interpreted through color, texture, technique, and emotional resonance.

A painting doesn’t just depict “things.” It invites us to feel, imagine, and see the world through the artist’s eyes. The still life of oranges doesn’t need to be revolutionary—it only needs to showcase the painter’s perspective and way of seeing.

Painting Shows What Lies Beyond the Physical Subject

A skilled artist doesn’t just paint what an object is. They use the language of art to explore how it exists. Every painting communicates beyond the surface of its physical subject by drawing from elements like color, value, composition, and edges.

When looking at a well-composed painting, try to focus on:

• Color harmonies: Notice how hues interact. Is there a striking contrast between warm and cool tones? Or, perhaps, subtle shifts in saturation?
• Value structure (light vs. dark): Observe how shadows and highlights sculpt the scene, creating dimension or drama.
• Edges: Are the transitions between elements soft and seamless, or sharp and defined? Artists use edges to guide your eye across the painting.
• Composition: Consider the placement of elements. Does the arrangement make your gaze linger in certain areas?

Take light as an example. Imagine a dappled beam cutting across a patio, illuminating a set of coffee cups. A painter focusing beyond the literal subject of “coffee cups” will study the interplay of textures—ceramic surfaces reflecting light, the soft glow of morning rays, and the way shadows create rhythm. It’s not about painting cups; it’s about capturing light.

When these elements shine, the subject itself becomes secondary—it’s the how, not the what, that resonates.

How to Make Your Painting About More Than the Subject Matter

Now that you know why subject matter is not the main event, how do you apply this in your own artistic practice?

Be Intentional with Your Art’s Subject Matter

Before picking what to paint, ask yourself why the subject appeals to you. Are you drawn to the literal object (like a vase of flowers because it’s pretty)? Or are you captivated by its visual qualities—the way the petals’ velvet texture plays against the glossy surface of a table?

Choosing for the visual richness of a subject leads to more dynamic, compelling paintings. Whether it’s a vast landscape or a single apple, your selection should inspire curiosity and exploration.

Create Visually Rich Setups

If you’re setting up a still life or composing a scene, think like a director crafting the perfect shot. Pay close attention to:

• Lighting: Where is the light source coming from? Does it create contrast and dimension? Dramatic light can transform even the simplest objects.
• Colors: Use props that interact harmoniously with each other, creating pleasing color accents and complements.
• Value Patterns: Consider the arrangement of light and dark—this helps structure your painting and move the viewer’s eye.

For a practical example, think of still-life masters. When arranging their compositions, they weren’t just tossing objects on a table. They carefully positioned each piece to orchestrate an immersive visual experience.

Observe Like a Painter, Always

Practice looking at the world through an artist’s lens—even when you’re not actively painting. Notice the shapes and colors of shadows, the way morning light changes a room, or how distant hills fade into blue-gray hues.

Whenever you strip away the subject’s literal identity (e.g., “this is a bowl”), you begin to observe in terms of visual properties instead. This deliberate practice helps train your eye and eventually translates into richer, more thoughtful paintings.

See the World Beyond the Subject Matter it Contains

Great art is never just about what you’re looking at—it’s about how it makes you feel, what it makes you imagine, and how it captures your attention. As an artist, it’s your job to guide your viewer beyond the object itself, into the world of light, shadow, color, and emotion.

Next time you’re painting, make an effort to see your subject not just as a “thing” but as a complex interplay of visual elements waiting to be explored. The more you practice seeing as an artist—whether you’re studying a bustling scene or a quiet still life—the more your work will reflect depth and understanding.

And remember, beautiful art is not dictated by subject matter. A thoughtful approach to how you paint will always outshine what you paint.

Want to remember this? Save Why Your Painting’s Subject Matter isn’t Important to your favorite Pinterest board!